Chapter Critique vs Manuscript Analysis vs Virtual Beta Reader
Chapter Critique, Manuscript Analysis, and Virtual Beta Reader all offer on-demand feedback for writers.
Chapter Critique is ideal for individual chapters or shorter pieces of text. It provides custom developmental critique feedback on plot, characters, pacing, descriptions, dialogue, and more, on up to 4,000 words, with a recommended minimum word count of 500 for meaningful results.
Manuscript Analysis is designed to run on larger pieces of text, like novels. It offers in-depth feedback on plot, characters, and structure to help strengthen your story. It can be used on up to 300,000 words with a recommended minimum word count of 4,000 words for best results.
Virtual Beta Reader works best on completed stories. It provides a reader’s perspective on your story, with insights into engagement, emotional impact, and overall reading experience. It’s best used after structural edits, on manuscripts between 4,000 and 300,000 words.
Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced writer, you can use any of these reports to receive instant feedback to improve your craft. Which one you should use depends on your text and the kind of analysis you need.
| Chapter Critique | Manuscript Analysis | Virtual Beta Reader | |
| What it does | Delivers custom feedback on the strengths, weaknesses, and areas for improvement of a single chapter of your story. | Provides comprehensive, accurate, and actionable analysis of characters, plot, and setting in your manuscript, considering the entire context of your story. Prioritizes which aspects to improve in your story, and provides the rationale for these suggested actions. | Offers feedback on your story from the reader’s perspective, helping you understand the reading experience, emotional journey, and how your story resonates overall. |
| Type of feedback it provides | Provides specific feedback for your chapter on the following key elements of creative writing: • Strengths • Plot/Story • Characters • Tension • Point of View • Setting • Style/Voice • Clarity/Cohesion • Writing Style • Description • Dialogue • Mood • Pacing • Potential Improvements |
The analysis provided is broken down into five sections: • About My Story: Gives you key information about your story’s genre, narrative elements, and competitive landscape. • Narrative Themes: Highlights the key narrative threads throughout your story, and flags themes that are working well along with themes that could use some adjustments. • Plot & Structure: Highlights plot points that are working well, as well as those that might need improvement. • Characters: Examines important characterization moments and highlights areas where a particular character is working well or could use some closer examination. • Setting: Analyzes how your use of setting contributes to the overall narrative structure of your manuscript. This section flags if you need to improve any aspect of your setting, and what you might do to make it stronger. |
The analysis provided is broken down into four sections: • General impressions: Highlights your story’s genre, audience, character presence, and how a reader engages with the story emotionally from chapter to chapter. • Reading experience: Captures the reader’s first impressions, emotional journey, character reactions, and how they experienced the story’s most intense moments. • Reading insights: Identifies key moments that stood out to the reader, highlights originality or clichés, and offers suggestions to explore in your next round of edits. • Marketing ideas: Offers marketing insights, including your ideal audience, title suggestions, and comparable books and characters your reader might associate with your story. |
| Recommended word count | Can be used in texts up to 4,000 words. For optimal critique, we recommend you analyze chapters of at least 500 words. |
Designed to run on larger pieces of text, like novels. Can be used on up to 300,000 words with a recommended minimum word count of 4000 words for best results. |
Best for completed stories between 4,000 and 300,000 words. |
| Is it included in your plan? | Included in all paid plans. Premium users get 1 Chapter Critique per day, and Premium Pro users get 3 Chapter Critiques per day. |
Not included. Available as an add-on. All users can buy credits in bundles of 1, 3, or 10 credits. Users with paid licenses receive special discounts on our standard rates. |
Not included. Available as an add-on. All users can buy credits in bundles of 1, 3, or 10 credits. Users with paid licenses receive special discounts on our standard rates. |
Have you tried Desktop Everywhere? Download for Windows or Mac to get editing suggestions and advanced analysis directly in Word, Scrivener, and all your favorite writing apps.